A late-1920s boxed set of paddle tennis equipment, similar to the one James Cogswell brought home

Perfect equipment already exists

One day, Cogswell turned up with some short rectangular-shaped paddles and spongy balls, which he discovered in a sporting goods store.

The equipment was used for paddle tennis, a game invented several years earlier by Reverend Frank Beal for cramped urban playgrounds. Beal and Frank Contessa had established the American Paddle Tennis association in 1922 to promote the game and market equipment – see Frank B. Contessa

Blanchard and Cogswell tried them out on their platform. After lowering the deck tennis net and a few bats back and forth, they knew they had made a discovery.

Source: Adapted from Fessenden S. Blanchard, Paddle Tennis, 1944 and Platform Paddle Tennis, 1959

Forty-five years after the founding of the Club, first President Thomas Burgess stands at left for a family portrait in Colonel Alexander B. Crane’s entrance hall.  

A new era dawns with the opening of the new clubhouse in 1927

Club Secretary Hynson spoke of a “renewal of activity worthy of the traditions of the oldest tennis club in Westchester County.” By June 1927 the directors were able to report: “On the strength of the new clubhouse and the good management of our officers, we have obtained about twenty-five or thirty additional active members” for a total of about one hundred active members. The plan was for a club of between 125 and 150 members “to guarantee us an income sufficient to pay the fixed charges and relieve us of the necessity of selling more property.”

Sally Jackson Rasmussen, who grew up in the new Jackson house on Church Lane, says that it always seemed to her to be sunny and peaceful at Fox Meadow Tennis Club. From the house, the Jacksons could see not only the Club, but the cows and sheep grazing next to it on Crane Meadow.

“There was nothing but sheep, cows, and the windmill,” Rasmussen recalls. “It was just too lovely. Richard Crane used to cavort along the meadow on his horse.”

Though life-styles were changing and life’s tempo increasing, the pace was still more leisurely than it is today. Sally Rasmussen remembers the Edmund Pearsons, good friends of her parents, who on Sundays would pack a lunch, walk to Scarsdale from their apartment in the Riverdale section of New York, and play tennis and picnic at Fox Meadow. Small and informal, the Club was still an oasis of tradition and time-honored formalities. Tennis whites were to be worn on the courts. And in 1927, shortly after the clubhouse opened, the Fox Meadow Tennis Club announced that it would hold a tea for members on Wednesday afternoons.

Source: Diana Reische, Fox Meadow Tennis Club – The First Hundred Years, 1983

FMTC property, 1927, showing land purchased from Emily Butler in 1923 and parcel sold to John Jackson in 1926

A clubhouse needed but raising money difficult; controversial land sale in 1926 to raise funds resulted in a number of member resignations but ultimately made the clubhouse a reality

For four years the Club tried to raise enough money for a clubhouse by selling stock, but it was unsuccessful. At the 1926 meeting of the Tennis Club, John Jackson proposed another means of getting cash: He moved that up to an acre of the Club’s property be sold to raise money to build a clubhouse and new tennis courts.

It is clear that the proposed land sale provoked considerable debate. Four of seven directors of the Tennis Realty Corporation, among them President Pfeiffer, Jackson, Kent, and Stowell, resigned from the board. Although resignations signed by Jackson and Stowell dated July 26, 1926, are in the minute’s books, both are listed as present for a special meeting of the Tennis Realty Corporation on that date. A draft of the minutes says the board discussed an offer of $10,000 from John Jackson to buy the southern half of land facing Church Lane, which he would use as a home-site. (The official minutes do not mention the offer.)

In September, a reshuffled Board of Directors accepted Jackson’s bid. It also authorized the president to sell a second half-acre of land on Church Lane. This decision was followed by another round of resignations from the boards of both the corporation and the Club, and the corporation’s board finally decided not to sell any more land.

The $10,000 sale to Jackson in 1926 made it possible at last for Fox Meadow Tennis Club to plan a clubhouse. Financing was completed by consolidating the old mortgage with a new loan in a note of $20,000 at six percent. Walter Collet, a Scarsdale contractor who built dozens of homes in the community, built the clubhouse, designed by Walter Pleuthner, for $9,000. The new clubhouse was a small stone building with a roofed porch along one side and a large stone chimney. Small and spare, it set a modest tone for the Club. With no bar and no dining room, the clubhouse helped establish the unpretentious family atmosphere that typifies Fox Meadow even today.

A committee of Mrs. Rudolph Culver, wife of the Club president; Edith Wilson; and Harriet Mason chose wicker and stained oak furniture for the new building.

Source: Diana Reische, Fox Meadow Tennis Club – The First Hundred Years, 1983

Alfred W. Haywood. President, 1925

Alfred W. Haywood elected FMTC President (1925)

Haywood was a native of North Carolina and studied law at the University of North Carolina and at Columbia University. He move to Scarsdale in the early 1920s and lived at 1000 Post Road. He became a member of the New York City law firm Moore, Hall, Swan & Cunningham in 1929 (Warren Cunningham served as mayor of Scarsdale and was also a FMTC member).

In 1933 Haywood, who had been a member Scarsdale Board of Education since 1926, was elected President and oversaw the building of the new Scarsdale High School during his tenure.

At the time of his election to President of FMTC the Scarsdale Inquirer of March 14, 1925 reported “the report of the treasurer showed the club in fine financial condition with a balance of $900 in the bank.”

Opening day of the new Fox Meadow clubhouse in 1927. The clubhouse was designed by noted architect Walter Pleuthner and built by Scarsdale contractor Walter Collet for $9,000.  

The dream realized – new courts and a clubhouse open in 1927

To celebrate, a full day of exhibition matches was planned for June 26, 1927. A number of notable players from around the country agreed to appear. Alas, rain fell the preceding night, turning the courts into quagmires. The skies cleared briefly about 9 a.m., renewing hope that the matches could be held. The courts were rolled once again, and the lines were redrawn. Another cloudburst erased the lines. Some of the visiting players suggested that, before rolling the courts again, Club officials burn off the dampness by pouring gasoline on the courts and lighting a fire. This was done, and finally, at 4 p.m., nearly 250 patient spectators were able to watch a match between Beryl Robinson, the Bermuda champion, and Mrs. Russell Downe of Greenwich. They played only one set on the still-slippery court, and Downe won 7-5.

After a men’s doubles match, the crowd watched the day’s highlight, a set pitting George King of New York, ranked tenth nationally, against Elmer Griffin of California. King had grown up in Scarsdale and had often played at Fox Meadow. Of the exhibition match, the Inquirer reported: “King’s fast serving and hard driving proved more effective than Griffin’s fast chop stroke and the set went to King 6-4.”

King returned to Fox Meadow three months later for an exhibition match against the nation’s top-ranked woman, Helen Wills. Arthur Driscoll umpired before a capacity crowd, and the match went to eight-all before King won a tie-breaker game.

Next came exhibition doubles with Wills and King paired against Alfred Hayden and Jim Hynson; then Wills and Hayden against King and Hynson. In both matches the Wills duo overwhelmed its opponents.

Source: Diana Reische, Fox Meadow Tennis Club – The First Hundred Years, 1983

Arthur F. Driscoll. President, 1923-1924

Arthur F. Driscoll elected FMTC President (1923-1924). A period of fun and tennis in the roaring ’20s

While there were behind-the-scenes difficulties in raising enough cash to build a clubhouse and new courts, for most members the 1920s were a time of good fun and good tennis. Pressure for court time in 1923 produced a rule that members could not bring as playing guests any nonmembers who lived in Scarsdale.

Though life-styles were changing, reminders of times past were very much in evidence on the Club grounds. Near the tennis courts there still were sheds for carriages, and when members played tennis, they still wore the costumes of a more genteel era: long sleeves, long skirts, long trousers.

“I always wore at least two of my prettiest lace-trimmed petticoats,” says Blanche Mason Starkweather of the costume a fashion-wise young lady wore for tennis at the Club circa 1921. “They came to the ankles, and of course when I ran for the ball, the lace showed.”

Two notices about women players appeared in 1923. The Scarsdale Inquirer ran a piece refuting a rumor that women could not use the courts on weekends. The paper said Fox Meadow was perhaps the only tennis club in the metropolitan district that did not limit use of the courts by women on holidays and weekends. Another item noted that an increased number of women playing tennis that year” has caused the appointment of a committee consisting of Mrs. Alfred Haywood, Mrs. Leland Stowell, and Miss Muriel Bray to arrange for Women’s Singles tournaments.”

In a burst of early environmental awareness, when a proposal was made in 1924 to cut down trees, Alfred Haywood rose to defend one particular elm. Such was his standing in the Club that the elm was left untouched, and it was duly noted that “this tree hereafter be known as the Haywood Preservation.”

Active recruiting added many new members, some of whom were still part of the Club at the time of the Centennial celebration in 1983.

Among them were James and Leila Hynson, who joined in 1924. A former Princeton tennis star, Jim quickly established himself as the Club’s strongest player, but Leila remembers the laughter at the Club as well as the tennis. She tells of a time when she was asked at the last minute to pinch-hit as her husband’s partner in a tournament: “At one point I was moved to say to him when a few successful returns of the ball had evidently turned my head, ‘I can’t carry you any longer.’ With the other players weakened with laughter, we won.”

Source: Diana Reische, Fox Meadow Tennis Club – The First Hundred Years, 1983

Theodore C. Jessup. President, 1921

Club informed that Butler land to be sold (1922) but offered first right of refusal on their leased land and two additional acres. Tennis Realty Corp. formed to acquire the land and title taken in 1923

Two years passed, and land prices rose sharply. In 1922 the Butlers informed the Club that the property it occupied would be put up for sale forthwith. The Club received first refusal for a three-acre site—encompassing the existing courts and two additional acres selling for $20,000, $5,000 more than in 1920.

Faced with this friendly but firm notice to buy or move out, the Club acted decisively. John Jackson (head of a special committee evaluating possible locations for a permanent home) was instrumental in reorganizing the Club so it could finance the purchase. The Club became two legal entities, a corporation that bought and held the property and a tennis club that leased it

The new Tennis Realty Corporation planned to issue capital stock of $20,000, divided into 400 shares, to be sold to old and new members at $50 a share. Each member could buy up to ten shares. As membership in the Club was to be limited to 200 families, it was hoped that many individuals would buy two or more shares. To remain in the Club, existing members had to buy a share in the corporation, and the initiation fee for incoming members was the purchase price of one share.

The organizers did not limit the plan to tennis players. The Scarsdale Inquirer reported in 1923: “It is the desire of the officers and Board of Governors to enroll upon the books of the Club all of the leading citizens of the town, whether tennis players or not. The Club is in reality strictly a community project and deserves the assistance and support of all.”

Dues were increased to $25 a year. There were four membership categories: voting, junior, season, and honorary. Any individual over the age of sixteen was eligible for voting membership if he or she held stock in the Realty Corporation.

The seven-member Board of Directors of the new Tennis Realty Corporation held its first meeting in August 1922 at the Yale Club in Manhattan. Founding directors were J. Lawrence Gilson, Alfred W. Haywood, John Jackson, Weyland Pfeiffer, Leland E. Stowell, Lester R. Stewart, and Warner W. Kent, all of Scarsdale.

The 1922 purchase deed forbade the buyer from building hotels, saloons, barrooms, or any places selling intoxicating liquor. Terms were $4,000 in cash, and a mortgage at six percent.

Despite initial optimism, stock sales lagged badly, and by the end of March 1923 only 38 of 400 shares had been sold. However, Emily Butler held the purchase agreement in abeyance while a new campaign was devised to attract members.

The Club finally took title to its own property in 1923, after forty years on bits of borrowed land.

Source: Diana Reische, Fox Meadow Tennis Club – The First Hundred Years, 1983

Rollin Kirby. President, 1920

Rollin Kirby elected FMTC President (1920); Pulitzer Prize winner for political cartoons

Rollin Kirby (9/4/1875–5/8/1952) served as president of Fox Meadow in 1920. He was an American political cartoonist who gave modern cartooning decisive impetus in the direction of graphic simplicity and high symbolic value.

He was born in Galva, IL and studied painting in New York City and Paris as a young man but switched to magazine illustrating and then cartooning. Kirby made his reputation during the 18 years (1913 to 1931) he spent on the New York World, where he won three Pulitzer Prizes for cartooning (1922, 1925, 1929).

He stayed with the paper when it merged with The World Telegram in 1931 and in 1939 he went to the New York Post, where he remained until 1942.

His cartoons later appeared in Look magazine and The New York Times Sunday Magazine.

He criticized Wall Street, New York’s political bossism, imperialism, fascism, and the Ku Klux Klan and crusaded for civil liberties, woman suffrage, and the New Deal.

He invented the long-nosed, sour Mr. Dry, who became widely known as the symbol of Prohibition. Although his drawing was outstanding, he considered the idea behind a cartoon far more important than the way it was drawn. In addition to his cartoon work, Kirby wrote verse, short plays, articles, editorials, and book reviews for various newspapers and magazines.

Source: Encyclopædia Britannica Online

Rollin Kirby – Distinguished political cartoonist and Pulitzer Prize Winner

Rollin Kirby – Distinguished political cartoonist and Pulitzer Prize Winner

Club informed that the land they had leased from 1911 could be sold (1920). Emily Butler was divesting her Fox Meadow holdings; options for alternative sites become a priority

For more than forty years the Tennis Club had borrowed or leased Fox Meadow land for a token sum. In 1920, however, a Butler representative alerted the Club that it might be asked to vacate immediately if and when the land it occupied on Church Lane was sold.

On July 24, 1920, FMTC members met at Town Hall to hear various proposals for buying or leasing a permanent site. The first of two possibilities was outlined by a representative of the Village Planning Board who suggested that the Club might lease a Fox Meadow tract from the Village and operate tennis courts there as a community service. A second option was to purchase four to five acres in an area of Scarsdale where prices were lower and more land could be bought. Members favored the second plan, and Club President Rollin Kirby named John Jackson, Pliny Williamson, William White, Oscar Williams, and Alan Chalmers to investigate and, if need be, to negotiate the purchase.

Less than a week later the special committee reported that Willard Parker Butler, Emily Butler’s representative (and cousin) would be willing to sell two and a half acres just west of the Club’s existing courts on Church Lane for $15,000. This was the site the Club ultimately bought, but in 1920 the board asked for more information on alternatives.

In December a special committee chaired by John Jackson told the board that Miss Butler would sell a three-acre site south of Wayside Lane for $15,000. The committee, however, recommended purchase of an alternate site, 4.72 acres south of Richbell Road on the Burgess property. The board took no action on either property, although at the 1921 annual meeting a “sense of the meeting” vote favored buying the Burgess land.

Source: Diana Reische, Fox Meadow Tennis Club – The First Hundred Years, 1983